Should Negan have killed Rick and his group? First...Let me say this...if, after everything, Negan still believes that he should have just killed everyone in season 7, then he didn't really learn anything while being imprisoned in Alexandria by Rick and the group other than he wants to be in power and have control. Moreover, Maggie should have simply killed him back when he was in prison, but she didn't and let him live. Negan has had a chance to redeem himself. He had a chance to give Rick's group a try. Negan has had YEARS of living amongst them. [READ MORE]